IndyaStory
Sign In
  • Latest
  • Business
  • Entrepreneurs
  • Finance
  • Markets
  • Economy
  • Leadership
  • Funding
  • Companies
  • AI
  • News
  • IPO
  • Innovation
  • Startup
  • Technology
IndyaStoryIndyaStory
  • Latest
  • Business
  • Entrepreneurs
  • Finance
  • Markets
  • Economy
  • Leadership
  • Funding
  • Companies
  • AI
  • News
  • IPO
  • Innovation
  • Startup
  • Technology
Search
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
Copyright © 2026 IndyaStory. All rights reserved.
Markets

SEBI Says Recusal Cases Involving Madhabi Puri Buch Are Not Readily Available

IndyaStory Staff
Last updated: October 2, 2026 8:07 pm
By
IndyaStory Staff
ByIndyaStory Staff
IndyaStory Staff is the editorial team at IndyaStory, an independent digital news platform covering Indian business, stock markets, IPOs, personal finance, banking, technology, and economic developments....
Follow:
Share
11 Min Read
SEBI RTI response on Madhabi Puri Buch recusal and financial declarations
SHARE

SEBI has said it does not have a readily available consolidated record of cases in which then-chairperson Madhabi Puri Buch recused herself because of potential conflicts of interest. The regulator also declined to provide copies or dates of certain financial declarations involving Buch and her family, citing exemptions under the RTI Act.

Contents
What SEBI said about the recusal recordsSEBI refuses copies of financial declarationsDates of the declarations were also not disclosedWhat the RTI response does not establishWhy recusal matters at a securities regulatorThe RTI Act contains exemptions for some personal informationThe distinction between public accountability and personal privacyWhy the recusal information is significantWhat happens after an RTI refusal?The broader governance questionWhat is known from the responseTransparency questions remain separate from the underlying claimsSEBI’s response in context

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has said that information on cases in which former chairperson Madhabi Puri Buch recused herself over potential conflicts of interest is not maintained in a form that is “readily” available.

The response came through an application filed under the Right to Information Act, 2005, according to the material supplied for this report.

In its reply to transparency activist Commodore Lokesh Batra (retd), SEBI said that identifying and compiling the requested recusal information would require a disproportionate diversion of the regulator’s resources.

- Advertisement -

See more of our coverage in your search results.

Add INDYASTORY on Google

The response also declined to provide copies of financial declarations made by Buch to the government and the SEBI Board concerning financial assets and equity holdings belonging to her and her family members.

What SEBI said about the recusal records

SEBI said the information requested on cases where Buch had recused herself because of potential conflicts was not readily available in a consolidated form.

The regulator stated:

“Since the information sought does not pertain to you and the same relates to personal information…”

It separately said that collating the information on recusal cases would result in a “disproportionately diverting” of the public authority’s resources.

The response cited Section 7(9) of the RTI Act in relation to the latter issue.

- Advertisement -

See more of our coverage in your search results.

Add INDYASTORY on Google

Section 7(9) concerns the form in which information is ordinarily provided where supplying it in a particular form could disproportionately divert the resources of a public authority.

That provision does not by itself establish whether the underlying information exists somewhere within an organisation; SEBI’s response, as supplied, says the requested information was not readily available in the form sought.

SEBI refuses copies of financial declarations

The RTI applicant also sought copies of declarations made by Buch to the government and the SEBI Board regarding financial assets and equity holdings held by her and family members.

- Advertisement -

See more of our coverage in your search results.

Add INDYASTORY on Google

SEBI declined to provide those documents.

The regulator cited Sections 8(1)(g) and 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, 2005.

According to the response, SEBI considered the requested material to constitute personal information whose disclosure could result in an unwarranted invasion of privacy and potentially affect the physical safety of the person or persons concerned.

The relevant portion of the response said the information:

“does not pertain to you and the same relates to personal information, the disclosure of which has no relationship with any public activity or interest…”

SEBI also referred to the possibility that disclosure could “endanger the life or physical safety” of the person or persons concerned.

Dates of the declarations were also not disclosed

The RTI applicant had also sought the dates on which the relevant declarations were submitted.

SEBI declined to disclose those dates as well, according to the supplied response.

The regulator used the same legal exemptions cited in its refusal to provide copies of the declarations.

As a result, the response did not provide the applicant with the requested documents or the dates of submission.

What the RTI response does not establish

The response should not automatically be interpreted as evidence that Buch did or did not have a conflict of interest in any particular matter.

The RTI question was about records of recusals and financial declarations, while SEBI’s answer concerned the availability and disclosure of those records.

Similarly, saying that information is not readily available is different from saying that no such information exists.

Any conclusion about whether a particular recusal took place, why it occurred or how it was handled would require separate documentary evidence.

Why recusal matters at a securities regulator

A recusal generally refers to an official stepping away from consideration of a matter because of an actual or potential conflict of interest.

For a financial-market regulator, conflict-management procedures are relevant because SEBI takes decisions affecting listed companies, intermediaries, investors and other market participants.

Documenting such recusals can therefore be relevant to questions about institutional governance and decision-making.

At the same time, information concerning an individual’s private financial holdings can involve privacy and security considerations, which are explicitly addressed by exemptions in the RTI framework.

The RTI Act contains exemptions for some personal information

The SEBI response relied on Section 8(1)(j), among other provisions.

The RTI Act contains exemptions covering certain categories of personal information and information whose disclosure may have implications for life or physical safety.

The precise application of these exemptions can depend on the nature of the information requested and the circumstances surrounding the disclosure.

SEBI’s response indicates that it considered the requested declarations to fall within those exemptions.

The distinction between public accountability and personal privacy

The dispute highlighted by the RTI application involves two competing considerations.

One is public transparency, particularly in relation to the conduct of a statutory financial-market regulator.

The other is privacy and security, particularly where the requested information concerns personal financial assets and family holdings.

The RTI framework attempts to balance those interests through its exemptions.

SEBI’s response shows that, in this case, the regulator applied those exemptions to the financial declarations and did not provide the requested documents.

Why the recusal information is significant

The applicant’s request for recusal records is distinct from the request for private financial declarations.

The first concerns official decision-making and potential conflicts.

The second concerns personal financial information.

SEBI’s response treated the two requests differently in substance, although both were ultimately subject to limitations on disclosure.

For the recusal request, the regulator pointed to the absence of a readily available consolidated record and the resources that would be required to compile it.

For the financial declarations, SEBI invoked statutory exemptions relating to personal information and safety.

What happens after an RTI refusal?

An RTI applicant who is dissatisfied with a response can pursue the appeal mechanisms provided under the law.

The RTI Act provides for a first appeal to the designated First Appellate Authority and, depending on the circumstances and outcome, a subsequent appeal or complaint before the relevant Information Commission.

Whether such a process occurs in this case would depend on the applicant’s next steps.

The mere issuance of an RTI response does not necessarily end the disclosure process.

The broader governance question

The SEBI response comes in the broader context of scrutiny of governance, conflicts of interest and disclosure standards at major financial regulators.

For a regulator overseeing India’s securities markets, questions concerning recusal procedures and conflict management can attract considerable public attention.

At the same time, any assessment of the underlying issues requires reference to actual records, applicable rules and the regulator’s formal processes rather than inference from the fact that particular information was not disclosed through an RTI response.

What is known from the response

Based on the material supplied, SEBI has stated three main things.

First, it said information on cases involving Buch’s recusal over potential conflicts was not readily available in the requested form and that compiling it could disproportionately divert resources.

Second, it declined to provide copies of financial declarations concerning Buch and her family, citing RTI exemptions relating to personal information and safety.

Third, it also declined to provide the dates on which those declarations were made.

Those are the contents of the regulator’s RTI response. They do not, on their own, establish the merits of any underlying allegation or conflict.

Transparency questions remain separate from the underlying claims

The RTI exchange may generate further questions about how conflict-of-interest records are documented within public authorities.

But those questions are distinct from determining whether any particular conflict actually existed or whether a specific official action was improper.

Answering those questions would require examining applicable SEBI rules, disclosure policies, recusal records where available, official correspondence and other documentary evidence.

That distinction is important when reporting on regulatory institutions and individual officeholders.

SEBI’s response in context

The episode illustrates one of the practical limits of India’s transparency regime.

The RTI Act provides a mechanism for accessing information held by public authorities, but it also contains exemptions and provisions concerning the form and burden of disclosure.

In this case, SEBI relied on those provisions to refuse some of the information requested and to explain why compiling another category of information would impose a disproportionate administrative burden.

The response therefore provides information about what SEBI was prepared to disclose, as well as what it was not prepared to provide through the RTI application.

TAGGED:Conflict of InterestMadhabi Puri BuchRight to InformationRTISEBISecurities and Exchange Board of India
Share This Article
Email Copy Link Print
ByIndyaStory Staff
Follow:
IndyaStory Staff is the editorial team at IndyaStory, an independent digital news platform covering Indian business, stock markets, IPOs, personal finance, banking, technology, and economic developments.Our team focuses on delivering timely news, clear explanations, and informative analysis to help readers understand important developments affecting businesses, markets, and everyday financial decisions.IndyaStory Staff articles aim to present complex financial and business topics in accessible English, with an emphasis on factual accuracy, relevant context, and reader value.
Previous Article OYO plans $525 million acquisition of Motel 6 and Studio 6 owner G6 Hospitality OYO to Acquire Motel 6 and Studio 6 Owner G6 Hospitality for $525 Million
Next Article Government awaits telecom companies' request after Supreme Court AGR decision Government Sees No Need for Immediate Legal Opinion After Supreme Court AGR Decision
Leave a Comment Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Read
Hybrid cars and plug-in hybrid SUVs representing future automotive technology in India with multiple manufacturers planning new launches by 2027

Hybrid Cars Make a Strong Comeback in India as Six Automakers Prepare New Launches by 2027

Renault Duster 2026 SUV Exterior and Interior India

Renault Duster 2026 Review: Can It Live Up to Its Legacy?

Lexus ES 500e 2026 Electric Sedan Exterior Interior India

2026 Lexus ES 500e EV: First Look at Lexus’ All-Electric Luxury Sedan

BYD Seal U plug-in hybrid SUV featuring DM-i technology and premium SUV styling

BYD Seal U PHEV Confirmed for India: New Hybrid SUV to Bring Over 1,200km Driving Range

2026 Tata Tiago EV electric hatchback with updated styling and modern EV design

2026 Tata Tiago EV Review: The Urban Electric Hatchback Gets Better

Upcoming Nissan Tekton SUV expected to launch in India in 2026

Nissan Tekton SUV Launch Date Revealed: Creta and Tata Sierra Rival to Arrive in India Soon

Upcoming Mahindra Vision S-based compact SUV with rugged SUV styling

Mahindra Vision S-Based Compact SUV Expected to Launch in 2027 With Competitive Pricing

Maruti Suzuki Victoris hybrid SUV parked on road

Maruti Suzuki Victoris Hybrid EMI Details: Monthly Installment After ₹3 Lakh Down Payment

2026 Audi Q7 luxury SUV with redesigned front fascia, split LED headlights and large grille

2026 Audi Q7 Unveiled: New Platform, Premium Interior and New Seating Options

Renault Duster 1.0 MT SUV parked on road showing rugged design and LED lighting

Renault Duster 1.0 MT Review: Is the Entry-Level Turbo SUV the Smartest Buy in the Lineup?

Related News
UnitedHealth Group office representing three U.S. senior spending stocks, including UNH, WELL and SNDA
Stock Market

UnitedHealth Stock and 2 U.S. Senior Spending Stocks to Watch as Retirement Costs Rise

Sensex rises over 1,500 points and Nifty crosses 24,400 during November 5, 2026 market rally
Market Insights

Sensex Jumps Over 1,500 Points, Nifty Crosses 24,400 as Oil Prices Slide: What’s Driving the Market Rally?

SEBI mutual fund net settlement rules effective April 1, 2027
Markets

SEBI Relaxes Cash Market Settlement Rules for Mutual Funds, New Framework From April 2027

Illustration of Indian stock market indices declining as GIFT Nifty signals a weak opening for Sensex and Nifty
Stock Market

GIFT Nifty Falls 185 Points, Signals Weak Sensex and Nifty Opening as Nasdaq, Asian Markets Plunge

Illustration of a falling US technology stock market chart amid concerns about AI company valuations
Markets

US Stock Market Sell-Off Raises AI Bubble Fears: Why Investors Are Questioning Big Tech’s Trillion-Dollar Investment Boom

Brands

  • TechLayers
  • Hunterfly
  • IndyaStory
  • Wkend
  • AI Story
  • SheZindagi
  • Hunterfly Style
  • Hunterfly Beauty

Topics

  • Nykaa
  • Zomato
  • Swiggy
  • Amazon
  • Cred
  • Meta
  • OpenAI
  • Microsoft

Financial Tools

  • SIP Calculator
  • EMI Calculator
  • Currency Converter
  • Home Rent vs Buy
  • Tax Calculator
  • Inflation Calculator
  • Loan Calculators
  • Wealth Calculators

Quick Links

  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Contact Us
  • Help Center
  • Prosenjit Barman
  • RSS Terms of Use

IS Buzz

Start your day with the latest business, tech, startup and entrepreneurship stories — delivered straight to your inbox in a quick five-minute read.
Copyright © 2026 IndyaStory. All rights reserved.
IndyaStory
Business Markets Economy Technology Innovation Startups Funding Fintech Opinion

Our Brands

TechLayers Tech & Innovation Hunterfly Women & Lifestyle IndyaStory Business & Economy The CapTop Markets & Investing Wkend Life, Work & Culture SheZindagi Women & Society Hunterfly Style Style & Lifestyle Hunterfly Beauty Beauty & Wellness IndyaStory AI AI Stories, News & Insights

Connect With Us

PitchUp ↗ Opens in a new tab List Your Company ↗ Opens in a new tab Media Kit →
Stay Ahead

Business, Markets &
Economic Insights

Explore the ideas, companies and market shifts shaping India’s economy.

Explore IndyaStory →
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?

Not a member? Sign Up